The infrastructure development cess imposed by Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa has been declared unconstitutional, with the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) ruling that a province cannot assume a fiscal power merely because parliament has not exercised it. In a detailed judgement issued this week, the court held that the levies encroached upon parliament’s exclusive authority over imports, exports and interprovincial trade, and that provincial legislation must yield where it conflicts with a competent federal law.
Why the Infrastructure Development Cess Failed Before the FCC
The 59-page judgement was authored by FCC Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan, and the two-judge bench also included Justice Aamer Farooq. It followed a verbal order announced a day earlier and disposed of a set of 568 challenges filed by different taxpayers against the cess. The levy was imposed in Sindh under the Sindh Development and Maintenance of Infrastructure Cess Act, 2017, and in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa under the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Infrastructure Development Cess Act, 2022.
The court explained that, although the statutory schemes and procedural histories of the two provinces differed, the cases raised one common constitutional question. It had to determine whether the levies, in their true nature and operation, fell within provincial legislative competence or intruded upon the federal domain. The FCC allowed the civil appeals filed by the taxpayers and set aside the judgements of the Sindh High Court and the Peshawar High Court, which had earlier upheld the provincial laws.
Having done so, the court declared the corresponding charging provisions, together with all dependent rules, notifications, assessments and recovery measures, unconstitutional and without lawful authority. The judgement stated that no demand, surcharge or penalty founded solely upon those charges would be enforced, and that securities furnished only for the invalid charges would be discharged upon verification, subject to any subsisting order governing their disposal.
Article 142 and the Primacy of Federal Law
Central to the ruling is the court’s reading of Article 142 of the Constitution. Chief Justice Khan observed that where a provincial law conflicts with a competent federal law, the federal law prevails and the provincial law becomes void to the extent of that conflict. The court also rejected the idea that silence on the part of parliament amounts to a transfer of power, holding that a failure to exercise a fiscal power does not mean the subject has passed to the provinces.
The judgement further drew a distinction between levying a tax and receiving its proceeds. According to the court, Article 160 of the Constitution and the applicable National Finance Commission arrangements separate the power to impose a federal tax from the entitlement to a share of its revenue. A province’s share, the court said, does not authorise it to impose that tax independently. It added that two competent levies are not unconstitutional merely because they affect the same goods, and that the defect in these cases was “legislative incompetence, not duplication.” Fiscal need, it noted, could not supply a power that the provinces did not possess.
Provincial Legislative Competence After the 18th Amendment
The FCC also addressed the argument that devolution had enlarged provincial authority. It observed that the abolition of the Concurrent Legislative List through the 18th Amendment had expanded provincial legislative competence but had not transferred subjects that were expressly retained in the federal domain. Provincial autonomy, the judgement said, must be given full effect within its constitutional sphere, while parliament’s exclusive authority over matters reserved to it must be preserved.
The court found that the high courts had given controlling weight to the infrastructure purpose of the cess, the movement of goods and its asserted compensatory character, without first establishing provincial legislative competence. None of these considerations, it held, offered an independent provincial basis for the challenged import, export and external transit charges.
Arguments Before the Court and What Remains Open to the Provinces
During the hearing, the taxpayers contended that the levies encroached upon parliament’s exclusive legislative domain and could not be sustained as fees or compensatory charges simply because the goods used provincial roads. They also challenged the collection arrangements, alleged discriminatory treatment, pointed to restrictions on trade and objected to retrospective validation. The provinces, for their part, invoked their residual legislative powers, their responsibilities for infrastructure and the services they provide to commercial users, and argued that the cess was distinct from customs duties.
The ruling does not, however, close the door on provincial revenue raising altogether. The FCC clarified that the provinces remain free to enact constitutionally competent infrastructure or service charges on goods that are manufactured and consumed within their own territories.
For businesses, the decision removes a levy that many importers and exporters had contested for years. For the provinces, it sets a clear boundary, confirming that the need to finance roads and other infrastructure cannot, on its own, justify a charge that falls within a subject reserved to parliament.
Follow SouthAsianDesk on X, Instagram and Facebook for insights on business and current affairs from across South Asia.
Read More:




